|
Planning for
Disabled Children
Americans are living
longer than they did in years past, including those with disabilities.
According to one count, 480,000 adults with mental retardation are
living with parents who are 60 or older. This figure does not include
adult children with other forms of disability nor those who live
separately, but still depend on their parents for vital support.
When these parents
can no longer care for their children due to their own disability or
death, the responsibility often falls on siblings, other family members,
and the community. In many cases, expenses increase dramatically when
care and guidance provided by parents must instead be provided by a
professional for a fee.
Planning by parents
can make all the difference in the life of the child with a disability,
as well as that of his or her siblings who may be left with the
responsibility for caretaking (on top of their own careers and caring
for their own families and, possibly, ailing parents). Any plan should
include the following elements:
A Plan of Care
Where is your son
going to live when he can no longer live with you? Will he move in with
a sibling? Or into a group home? Who will make the decision? Who will
monitor the care he receives? It’s never too soon to begin answering
these questions and making sure that the living and support arrangements
are in place.
In some cases, it
can ease the transition for all concerned if the child moves to the new
living arrangement while his parents can still help with the process. In
many parts of the country, non-profit organizations and private
consultants can help set up the plan, research available options, and
assist in the move.
It will help
everyone involved if the parents create a written statement of their
wishes for their child’s care. They know him better than anyone else.
They can explain what helps, what hurts, what scares their child (who,
of course, is an adult), and what reassures him. When the parents are
gone, their knowledge will go with them unless they pass it on.
In almost all cases
where a parent will leave funds at death to a disabled child, this
should be done in the form of a trust. Trusts set up for the care of a
disabled child generally are called "supplemental" or "special" needs
trusts, which are described in more detail below.
Money should not go
outright to the child, both because she may not be able to manage it
properly and because receiving the funds directly may cause the child to
lose public benefits, such as Supplemental Security Income (SSI) and
Medicaid. Often, these programs also serve as the entry point for
receiving vital community support services.
Some parents choose
to avoid the complication of a trust by leaving their estates to one or
more of their healthy children, relying on them to use the funds for the
benefit of their disabled siblings. Except in the case of a very small
estate, this is generally not a good idea. It puts the healthy child in
the difficult position of having to decide how much of her money to
spend on her sibling. Such funds also will be subject to claim by
creditors and at risk in the event of divorce or bankruptcy. Finally,
the child who receives the funds may die before the disabled child
without setting these funds aside in her estate plan.
Life Insurance
Finally, a parent
with a disabled child should consider buying life insurance to fund the
supplemental needs trust set up for the child’s support. What may look
like a substantial sum to leave in trust today may run out after several
years of paying for care that the parent had previously provided. The
more resources available, the better the support that can be provided
the child. And if both parents are alive, the cost of "second-to-die"
insurance--payable only when the second of the two parents passes
away--can be surprisingly low.
The good news is
that advance planning for a disabled child can make a significant
difference in his life. You just have to take the first step.
Supplemental Needs Trusts
Supplemental needs
trusts (also known as "special needs" trusts) allow a disabled
beneficiary to receive gifts, lawsuit settlements, or other funds and
yet not lose her eligibility for certain government programs. Such
trusts are drafted so that the funds will not be considered to belong to
the beneficiary in determining her eligibility for public benefits. As
their name implies, supplemental needs trusts are designed not to
provide basic support, but instead to pay for comforts and luxuries that
are not available from public assistance. These trusts typically pay for
things like education, recreation, counseling, and medical attention
beyond the simple necessities of life. (However, the trustee can use
trust funds for food, clothing and shelter if the trustee decides doing
so is in the beneficiary’s best interest despite a possible loss or
reduction in public assistance.)
Very often,
supplemental needs trusts are created by a parent or other family member
for a disabled child (even though the child may be an adult by the time
the trust is created or funded). Such trusts also may be set up in a
will as a way for an individual to leave assets to a disabled relative.
In addition, the disabled individual can often create the trust himself,
depending on the program for which he or she seeks benefits. These
"self-settled" trusts are frequently established by individuals who
become disabled as the result of an accident or medical malpractice and
later receive the proceeds of a personal injury award or settlement.
Each public benefits
program has restrictions that the supplemental needs trust must comply
with in order not to jeopardize the beneficiary’s continued eligibility
for public benefits. Both Medicaid and SSI are quite restrictive, making
it difficult for a beneficiary to create a trust for his or her own
benefit and still retain eligibility for Medicaid benefits. But both
programs allow two "safe harbors" permitting the creation of
supplemental needs trusts with a beneficiary's own money if the trust
meets certain requirements.
The first of these
is called a "payback" or "(d)(4)(A)" trust, referring to the authorizing
statute. "Payback" trusts are created with the assets of a disabled
individual under age 65 and are established by his or her parent,
grandparent or legal guardian or by a court. They also must provide that
at the beneficiary's death any remaining trust funds will first be used
to reimburse the state for Medicaid paid on the beneficiary's behalf.
Medicaid and SSI law
also permits "(d)(4)(C)" or "pooled trusts." Such trusts pool the
resources of many disabled beneficiaries, and those resources are
managed by a non-profit association. Unlike individual disability
trusts, which may be created only for those under age 65, pooled trusts
may be for beneficiaries of any age and may be created by the
beneficiary herself. In addition, at the beneficiary's death the state
does not have to be repaid for its Medicaid expenses on her behalf as
long as the funds are retained in the trust for the benefit of other
disabled beneficiaries. (At least, that’s what the federal law says;
some states require reimbursement under all circumstances.) Although a
pooled trust is an option for a disabled individual over age 65 who is
receiving Medicaid or SSI, those over age 65 who make transfers to the
trust will incur a transfer penalty.
Income paid from a
supplemental needs trust to a beneficiary is another issue, particularly
with regard to SSI benefits. In the case of SSI, the trust beneficiary
would lose a dollar of SSI benefits for every dollar paid to him
directly. In addition, payments by the trust to the beneficiary for
food, clothing or housing are considered "in kind" income and, again,
the SSI benefit will be cut by one dollar for every dollar of value of
such "in kind" income. Some attorneys draft the trusts to limit the
trustee's discretion to make such payments. Others do not limit the
trustee's discretion, but instead counsel the trustee on how the trust
funds may be spent, permitting more flexibility for unforeseen events or
changes in circumstances in the future. The difference has to do with
philosophy, the situation of the client, and the amount of money in the
trust.
Choosing a trustee
is also an important issue in supplemental needs trusts. Most people do
not have the expertise to manage a trust. An alternative is retaining
the services of a professional trustee. For those who may be
uncomfortable with the idea of an outsider managing a loved one’s
affairs, it is possible to simultaneously appoint a trust "protector,"
who has the powers to review accounts and to hire and fire trustees, and
a trust "advisor," who instructs the trustee on the beneficiary’s needs.
However, if the trust fund is small, a professional trustee may not be
interested. This can be an argument for pooled trusts.
Qualified Income Trusts ("Miller" Trusts)
Tennessee has an “income cap” that can disqualify Medicaid applicants
who have gross incomes above
$1,911.00 per month (2008). Fortunately, federal law
does allow the Medicaid applicant’s income to be placed into an
irrevocable qualified income trust (QIT). The income that is placed in
the qualified income trust’s bank account each month will not be counted
for purposes of the income cap limit, and will permit the applicant to
qualify for Medicaid for nursing home care.
A
qualified income trust is an irrevocable trust that contains only the
regular monthly income of the individual. Elder lawyers developed these
trusts, which were finally approved in a federal court case,
Miller v. Ibarra. (The QIT
is sometimes called a “Miller” trust for that reason.) Their use was
incorporated into federal law (at 42 U.S.C. Sec. 1396p(d)(4)(B)) in the
1993 revisions to the Social Security Act.
These
trusts should be prepared by an experienced estate planning attorney
licensed in the state where the trust is to be used. The attorney the
client selects should be one who understands these trusts and can
explain to the trustee how they are used. This article is not intended
to act as a substitute for competent legal advice about the client’s
particular situation and trust needs.
The
trust must be signed by two people: the
Trustee and the
Grantor. The grantor is
the nursing home resident whose monthly income is funding the trust. The
trustee is
responsible for paying the grantor’s nursing home related expenses by
writing trust checks to the nursing home and other recipients as
instructed by the Tennessee Department of Human Services (DHS). If the
grantor is not mentally competent to sign the document, his
attorney-in-fact under a valid durable power of attorney (POA) can sign
the trust for him. If there is no POA, it will be necessary to have a
conservator appointed by the probate or chancery court and authorized to
sign for the incompetent grantor. The trustee can also be the
attorney-in-fact or the conservator.
After
the trust agreement is signed, the trustee must open a new bank account
in the name of the trust. The trust is a “grantor trust” for tax
purposes, and the Tax Identification Number on the account should be the
Social Security Number of the grantor.
A copy
of the executed trust and proof of deposit of income into the new trust
bank account must be presented to DHS before the Medicaid application is
complete. DHS will not approve Medicaid for any month before the QIT is
funded.
Each month thereafter, the grantor’s income must be transferred from the
grantor’s account and deposited into the trust bank account. The trustee
then is required to pay the money out of the trust to the approved
payees.
Note that Tennessee DHS currently allocates $20 each month for monthly
bank charges, though the actual expenses will be significantly less.
Each month, after payment of the patient’s nursing home liability, there
should be left in the account only about $20 from that month’s income,
plus any accumulation from prior months.
The trustee is required to file an annual accounting to the DHS. The
accounting will show all income received, checks written, and balance of
the account. The trustee should save all bank statements for this
purpose. The trustee holds the remaining balance of the trust account
until the grantor dies.
Upon
the death of the grantor, the trustee must notify DHS, which should send
the trustee a letter stating the amount that was paid for the grantor’s
care. The remaining trust balance is paid to the state to help re-pay
the nursing home expenses that were paid by Medicaid. The trustee must
pay the trust account balance as ordered by Tennessee Medicaid (TennCare)
after the final monthly checks have cleared.
|